This post is designed to teach you how to make simple Dairy Free Mashed Potatoes. With my simple Dairy Free Mashed Potato Recipe, you will have smooth, buttery, and tasty mashed potatoes any time you want. This Dairy Free Mashed Potato Recipe is gluten free, dairy free, soy free, egg free, and nut free. It is also suitable for vegans and vegetarians.
Thanksgiving will be here before we know it. If you are dairy free or vegan you might be dreading making substitutes for your Thanksgiving meal. Luckily mashed potatoes do not have to be a challenge. These dairy free mashed potatoes are so easy to make. With just a few simple tweaks you’ll have delicious dairy free mashed potatoes on your dinner table. If you want gluten free gravy to go along with your dairy free mashed potatoes, click here to learn How to Make Gluten Free Gravy.
Two things need to be replaced to make your mashed potatoes dairy free. Milk and butter. Here are the ways I replace milk and butter in my dairy free mashed potatoes. These replacements are easy and if you are dairy free you probably already have the ingredients on hand.
Which Milk Substitute Should I Use?
The biggest question I see when it comes to making dairy free mashed potatoes is, “what milk substitute should I use?”. Different people will tell you different things. But through much trial and error, I have determined you shouldn’t use any milk substitute in your dairy free mashed potatoes. Or at least not very much at all. When you simply replace milk cup for cup in dairy free mashed potatoes you usually end up with some weird flavors. As much as I love dairy free milk, it does not work well in MOST savory meals. Even if you buy unsweetened versions of dairy free milk you are still left with a strong coconut flavor, almond flavor, oat flavor, etc. For that reason, I don’t use dairy free milk as the primary liquid in dairy free mashed potatoes.
The primary liquid used to make my dairy free mashed potatoes creamy is water. Yes, just water. I prefer to use the water that the potatoes were boiled in because it is a bit more starchy. However, if you forget to reserve that water, you can use plain water. I do add a tiny bit of dairy free milk for a milk-like flavor. But trust me, a little bit of dairy free milk goes a long way. I am using unsweetened almond milk. If you don’t have that on hand don’t worry. Since I am only adding a tiny bit of dairy free milk to this recipe you can use whatever kind you have on hand. And if you don’t have any dairy free milk on hand, just skip it. I’ve done that before and the results are pretty similar.
How to Replace Butter
Luckily there are many good dairy free margarine available these days. I like to add a good amount of dairy free margarine to my mashed potatoes because it makes up for the lack of milk. By adding extra dairy free margarine you achieve a deliciously rich and creamy texture and taste.
I can’t speak to every dairy free butter option, but I have successfully used Soy Free Earth Balance and Smart Balance. Both are great brands with great dairy and soy free butter products.
If you like this post or any other recipe on the blog then don’t forget to scroll down to the comments section to rate the recipe ☆☆☆☆☆ and let me know your questions, thoughts, and opinions. I love hearing from you! If you think your friends would love this recipe too, don’t forget to hit the share buttons below.
Dairy Free Mashed Potatoes
- 5 russet potatoes
- 1/4 cup dairy free butter - so note in blog for brand ideas
- 1/2 teaspoon salt - add more or less to taste
- 1/4 teaspoon pepper - add more or less to taste
- 1 tablespoon dairy free milk - see note in blog post about dairy free milk
- 1 cup water that potatoes were boiled in
- Peel your potatoes according to your preference. I like some skin left on so I don't peel them perfectly. Cut your potatoes into large chunks to help them cook faster while boiling.
- Fill a large pot with cold water and add in your potato chunks. Boil your potato chunks for about 25 minutes or until a fork inserted into a potato chunk goes in extremely easily. I like my potatoes cooked very well because it ensures you will have smooth mashed potatoes.
- Before you drain your potatoes use a mug to remove some water. I usually reserve two mugs full of the cooking water just in case I need extra. Once you have reserved your water drain your potatoes in a colander.
- Add cooked potatoes to your stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment. Add in your dairy free butter, salt, and pepper. Mix on medium-low until potatoes are mashed. With the mixer on the lowest setting add in your dairy free milk and slowly add in your water. Start with about half the water and add the rest slowly until you reach your desired consistency.
- You can eat your mashed potatoes right away or reheat them in a pot if needed. If reheating you may need to add a bit more water to make sure they are not too dry.
For more recipes like this be sure to check out the following posts:
If you are brand new to Eat or Drink be sure to sign up for the newsletter so you never miss a thing.
Want more Eat or Drink Content? You can also FOLLOW ME on INSTAGRAM, FACEBOOK, and PINTEREST. There you’ll see more delicious food and to see some social media exclusive recipes, tips, and giveaways.
I didn’t even know you could make dairy free mashed potatoes! We have some dairy free guests this year and now I know what to do!
Oh yay!! So happy this could be a help for you!
I love using a little dairy free spread to make the mash slightly creamier. Great post, thank you for sharing.
Yess I think without the milk a good amount of dairy free margarine really helps make them delicious!
Mashed potatoes are just the best side dish and this dairy free version is perfect for everyone!
I totally agree a very easy and perfect side! Thanks!
An awesome share in time for the holiday season. I am sure vegans and lactose intolerant are going to enjoy it. I can see others enjoying it as well.
Thanks so much!!
This is a wonderful recipe for the many people that can’t eat dairy but still want to enjoy mashed potatoes. Thank you for sharing!
This is such a great recipe for anyone who can’t have dairy. Plus, they look so delicious that dairy lovers will still enjoy them, too!
Thank you!! Yes for sure, this is one of those recipes that you could make for people with allergies and people without allergies won’t even notice the difference!
Oh this is so interesting Emily! I have never considered making them without butter before, but I am glad that you have showed me the way to do it. It looks exactly the same as mash with melted butter and cow’s milk!!
Yes, it’s great if you have friends or family with allergies, especially with the holiday’s coming up! Thanks so much!
It’s always so nice to have these options for friends with allergies! Thank you for the wonderful recipe!
Yes exactly! Even if you don’t have allergies it’s good to know these simple tweaks for your friends. Thanks!
I didn’t even know you could do dairy free potatoes! they still look so light and fluffy!
Yes! Luckily it’s not hard to make these few changes, you just have to know the best substitutes. Thanks!